Sensory discrimination and intelligence: Testing Spearman's other hypothesis

IAN J.DEARY, P.JOSEPH BELL, ANDREW J.BELL,
MARY L.CAMPBELL,and NICOLA D.FAZAL
University of Edinburgh

At the centenary of Spearman's seminal 1904 article,his general intelligence hypothesis remains one of the most influential in psychology.Less well known is the article's other hypothesis that there is "a correspondence between what may provisionally be called 'General Discrimination' and 'General Intelligence' which works out with great approximation to one or absoluteness" (Spearman,1904,p. 284).Studies that do not find high correlations between psychometric intelligence and single sensory discrimination tests do not falsify this hypothesis.This study is the first directly to address Spearman 's general intelligence-general sensory discrimination hypothesis.It attempts to replicate his findings with a similar sample of schoolchildren.In a well-fitting structural equation model of the data,general intelligence and general discrimination correlated .92.In a reanalysis of data published by Acton and Schroeder (2001),general intelligence and general sensory ability correlated .68 in men and women.One hundred years after its conception,Spearman's other hypothesis achieves some confirmation. The association between general intelligence and general sensory ability remains to be replicated and explained.